Troyer's Marketplace: Your Destination for Quality Meats, Bulk Foods, and Homemade Delights in Johnstown, OH

My favorite place for spices and they have an amazing salad in their deli that I probably go once or twice a month and get

A quaint Amish Country store. Sells primarily food items. Has many unique food items, including fresh made cinnamon rolls, donuts, and fry pies. In addition there is a fresh deli with seats where you can get a sandwich made to order. Best place to get baking supplies in bulk.

There are so many things at this store that you don't realize you need them! Spices, candy, baked goods, vegetables lunch meat, cheeses, it just goes on and on! They even have a dining in area where you can have lunch, salads and sandwiches or snacks. Staff are very friendly and helpful, my favorite thing is the chicken salad. It's delicious!

Great Amish supermarket with a little restaurant. Sweets galore. They also have a big deli. The service is great as well. I will definitely be back.

I love troyers! The garlic bagels are fantastic. Hot pepper cheese spread, so good! Kansas city burnt end dip is the bomb. And to round it out, the big daddy donut is always fresh fluffy and melts in your mouth! It lasts me a whole week if i behave! Lol those are just a few of the items I get! I go just about every week!! Everything i have had is delicious!

Some of the best donuts around. The cream sticks have sweet cream filling on the inside, which I like. I don't care for the sour tasting cream filling that some places like Der Dutchman has. Muffins and bagels are also very good too. Nice selection of baking and dry goods as well. Lunch meat and refrigerated sides are all high quality and taste good.

Hands down this should be a 5-star review - except I ordered a Reuben, and I need to make a point. When you are making deli sandwiches and you have FULL ACCESS to a deli counter - that needs to be a good sandwich. Why wasn’t it on a hearty rye bread that could stand up to the weight of meat, cheese, kraut and sauce? It was on white sandwich bread that got soggy with all the guts of the sandwich. And then spent a few steamy minutes in a styrofoam clamshell before I got my grubby hands on it. The bread was grilled to perfection- but was simply not substantial enough for the job. The sauce was also a bit sweet for me, but I’m fine with that. Everyone can make their sandwich their own. But that bread choice ruined my experience while eating a known-to-be messy sandwich even messier to eat in the car. I loved everything else about my first visit. I always need a Troyer pie when I find them , and I got a few donuts to go as well. If I hadn’t been on my way to a Christmas party in Pickerington, I would have shopped even more. One other exciting facet of the visit was sampling Snacks with a Twist. Their pineapple/habanero spread with flavored pretzels is exactly what everyone needs as a little pick me up. So you can see, if I had only rated the sandwich - it would have been a 2 or a 3, I was so disappointed. But it’s the whole experience which would have been a solid 5 if I hadn’t stepped up to the concession counter. Let me know when you get a loaf of rye in… I’ll come back and raise my rating!

If you like to get some good pastries and jams. I recommend going to Troyer’s Marketplace. Also they have all kinds of spices, candies and a meat counter. Some fresh vegetables and fruit. The only thing I would have liked to have gotten was a jar of blackberry jam with seeds in it. I know some people don’t like the seeds. My husband and I do